Why do people protest, and do protests work?
Protests have long been a powerful tool for social change, but what motivates individuals to take to the streets, and what factors contribute to the effectiveness of such movements? These questions were at the forefront of a thought-provoking lecture held on May 6, 2023, organized by SciLine and featuring insights from leading scholars in sociology, psychology, and activism.
The Catalysts of Protest
According to David S. Meyer, a Professor of Sociology at the University of California, Irvine, the decision to participate in a protest hinges on a belief that something is wrong and that change is both possible and achievable through collective action. Similarly, Lauren Duncan, a Psychology Professor at Smith College, highlights the role of perceived injustice, often tied to social identities, in motivating individuals to join movements for change.
The Psychology Behind Participation
Fathali Moghaddam, a Professor of Psychology at Georgetown University, delves into the psychological underpinnings of protest participation, pointing to the interplay between arousal and ideology. He suggests that individuals are more likely to engage in protests when emotionally stirred by events that resonate with their beliefs.
The Seeds of Social Movements
Amy Binder, a Professor of Sociology at Johns Hopkins University, challenges the notion that protests arise out of nowhere, emphasizing the presence of underlying grievances and organized efforts that precede public demonstrations. She highlights the role of networks and leadership structures in mobilizing movements, often in response to catalyzing events.
Factors Shaping Protest Effectiveness
When considering the effectiveness of protests, Lauren Duncan stresses the importance of garnering support from the broader populace. Extreme actions, she notes, may alienate the moderate majority, emphasizing the need for strategic messaging and mobilization efforts.
Andrew Martin, a Sociology Professor at Ohio State University, echoes this sentiment, emphasizing the significance of mobilizing volunteers, gaining positive media attention, and employing innovative tactics to capture public imagination.
Fathali Moghaddam adds that aligning with prevailing ideologies can enhance a movement’s effectiveness by resonating with existing public sentiments.
Navigating Responses to Protests
As protests unfold, authorities face critical decisions on how to respond. Lauren Duncan underscores the need for administrators to recognize the developmental significance of protest among students and to avoid heavy-handed tactics that may provoke backlash.
David S. Meyer warns against repressive measures, cautioning that harsh responses can backfire, generating sympathy for protesters and elevating their cause.
Andrew Martin emphasizes the delicate balance between maintaining public order and upholding constitutionally protected rights of assembly and free speech.
Fathali Moghaddam extends this discussion to the international arena, urging governments to consider the alignment of their responses with principles of justice on both domestic and global scales.
Journalistic Perspectives
When covering protest movements, Lauren Duncan advises journalists to engage directly with protesters to understand their motivations and experiences, acknowledging the diversity of perspectives within any given movement.
David S. Meyer encourages journalists to focus on the sincere intentions of activists and to contextualize events within broader narratives of social change.
Andrew Martin advocates for a holistic approach to reporting, urging journalists to explore the organizational dynamics and historical context behind protests rather than fixating on sensationalized aspects.
Fathali Moghaddam emphasizes the importance of global perspective, urging journalists to frame protests within broader socio-political contexts.
Amy Binder highlights the value of local journalism in providing nuanced insights into community dynamics and encourages journalists to provide historical context for current events.
Conclusion
As societies grapple with pressing issues, from social inequality to environmental degradation, protests continue to serve as a catalyst for change. By understanding the psychological, sociological, and strategic factors underlying protest movements, individuals, authorities, and journalists alike can navigate these turbulent waters with greater insight and empathy, ultimately fostering a more informed and engaged civil discourse.
For more: https://www.sciline.org/social-sciences/protests-sociology-psychology/?utm_source=email&utm_medium=2023-opt-in-journalists&utm_campaign=quotes-from-experts-2024-protests-sociology-psychology&utm_content=image